For The Table...
Steakhouse Bacon
thick cut slab bacon, brown sugar glaze, pickled vegetable
$16.00
Fried Calamari
spicy pomodoro, lemon & confit garlic aioli
$18.00
Mussels Arrabbiata
nova scotia mussels, OTB spicy pomodoro, basil, parsley
$15.00
Twice Baked Potato
braised short rib, aged cheddar, sour cream, chive
$18.00
Grilled Octopus
marinated octopus, warm farro salad, pepper agrodolce
$24.00
Bacon Jam Burger Sliders
aged cheddar, toasted brioche, bacon & onion jam, pickle
$18.00
Bay Fries
seasoned & hand cut served with our famous fry sauce
$15.00
Soups
French Onion Soup
garlic crostini, melted swiss & gruyere
$11.00
New England Clam Chowder
local clams, bacon lardons, cream, fresh herbs
$14.00
Seafood Chowder
tomato broth, shrimp, mussels, clams
$15.00
Salads
Burrata Salad
arugula, fresh burrata, pickled red onion, lemon thyme vinaigrette, roasted beets
$16.00
Caesar Salad
romaine, housemade caesar, shaved parmesan, garlic crostini
$14.00
The Bay Salad
market greens, cajun shrimp, roasted carrot, bacon, buttermilk ranch
$28.00
On Bread
Buttermilk Chicken Sandwich
toasted brioche, buttermilk fried chicken, house cabbage slaw, spicy aioli
$22.00
Off The Bay Steakhouse Burger
short rib & brisket blend, toasted brioche, caramelized pork belly, aged cheddar, bibb lettuce, tomato, pickle, spicy aioli
$25.00
Shrimp Po' Boy
crispy cajun jumbo shrimp, tomato, lettuce, tartar sauce
$28.00
French Dip
slow roasted prime ribeye, swiss & gruyere, au jus
$32.00
Lobster Roll
Maine lobster, citrus seafood aioli, fresh herbs, scallion
$38.00
Entrées
Grilled Swordfish
8oz skin off swordfish steak, peperonata, fresh lemon, served with pepper agrodolce
$36.00
Prime Rib
slow roasted prime ribeye, au poivre sauce
$48.00
Best Chicken On The Block
frenched Bell and Evans Chicken, lemon & white wine au jus, pepper agrodolce
$26.00
Lobster Tagliatelle
1¼ lb Maine lobster, lemon cream sauce, blistered cherry tomato, herbs
$48.00
Fish & Chips
fresh Atlantic hake, malt vinegar, tartar, lemon
$28.00
Sides
Charred Broccolini
with crispy garlic
$14.00
Roasted Tricolor Carrots
in a sweet and savory herb butter
$12.00
Risotto
add lobster MP
$12.00
Off the Bay Sayville
Support local businesses while treating your tastebuds! Try some of the top pizzas in Sayville and find a new favorite. Off the Bay Sayville remains one of the most popular in Sayville. Give them a try and see what makes them such a favorite. For a true flavor of the city, try some of Sayville's top dishes. See what all the fuss is about with these local favorites. Don't forget to add fried calamari to your order. See why this delicious item is a local favorite. This reliable restaurant has been a Slice partner for one year. You can count on them providing something tasty. Curbside pickup at Off the Bay Sayville makes things easy. Place an order, and it'll be ready for you to pick up at your convenience. Off the Bay Sayville accepts credit cards. That makes it easy to get your pizza sooner.